Australia Scholarships for International Students from Developing Countries 2016-2017. Find Bachelors, Masters, & PhD Degree Scholarships in Australia.
Thursday, April 19, 2012
Post-Publication Peer Review: What Value Do Usage-Based Metrics Offer?
Posted by David Crotty ⋅ Apr 19, 2012⋅ 13 Comments
A PLoS ONE article recently went viral, hitting the front page of Reddit and garnering an amazing amount of reader interest. This was great news for the journal and the paper’s authors, but raises questions for the notion of post-publication peer review.
As Kent Anderson recently discussed, the idea of post-publication peer review is nothing new — it’s called “science”. Publication of the paper is an end of one process but the beginning of another. [snip].
The proposed revolution then, is not in the concept, but in the tools available, ways to open that conversation worldwide and to track the life of that paper after it has been published, to better measure its true impact. Despite initial momentum, movement toward implementation of these new technologies seems to have hit a stalling point.
[snip]
Doing away with pre-publication peer review and replacing it entirely seems to have garnered little support in the research community. F1000 Research will be the biggest test of whether this has any viability. Their approach seems more a strategy meant to increase publisher revenue, rather than to benefit researchers. [snip].
[snip]
That leaves the search for new metrics (“altmetrics“) as perhaps the greatest hope for near-term improvement in our post-publication understanding of a paper’s value. The Impact Factor is a reasonable, if flawed measurement of a journal, but a terrible method for measuring the quality of work in individual papers or from individual researchers. [snip]
[snip]
Metrics based on social media coverage of an article tell us more about the author’s ability to network than about their actual experiments. Metrics based on article usage are even harder to interpret as they offer information on reader interest and subject popularity, rather than quality of the article itself.
[snip]
For the mainstream of science journals, usage based metrics don’t seem to offer the much-desired replacement for the Impact Factor. There is value in understanding the interest drawn by research, but that value is not the same as measuring the quality of that research.
So far we’re mining all the easy and obvious metrics we can find. But they don’t offer us the information we really need. Until better metrics that truly deliver meaningful data on impact are offered, the altmetrics approach is in danger of stalling out. This points to a major crossroads for the field.
Like so many new technologies, there’s an initial rush of enthusiasm as we think about how it could fit with scholarly publishing. But then we hit a point where the easy and obvious approaches are exhausted without much return. Now the hard work begins.
Source and Fulltext Available At
[http://bit.ly/IQ9W2N]
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Popular Posts
-
NATIONAL BANK OF GREECE POST-DOCTORAL RESEARCH FELLOWSHIP HELLENIC OBSERVATORY (EUROPEAN INSTITUTE) Salary: £32,148 - £38,887 pa incl. Fixed...
-
JoVE: What is it? Journal of Visualized Experiments ( JoVE ) is an online video-publication for biological research. [ http://www.jove.co...
-
"Beyond Forum Alpbach – Sarajevo World Cafè 2012" I am pleased to invite you to the first session within the project "Beyond...
-
East European Studies Junior Scholars' Training Seminar Program Scholarship // Application Deadline: Apr 15, 2012 Deadline: The deadline...
-
The SEE University is very pleased to announce this national conference on 12 June, 2012, Tetovo Campus Macedonia . Details and call for ab...
-
Masters Scholarship in the field of Jewish Studies for international students, Tel Aviv University, Israel 2012-2013 Study Subject(s):Jewish...
-
University of Hawai‘i Maui College (UHMC)Merit Scholarship Program is High School applicants to pursue undergraduate at Maui College, 2012...
-
In the late 18th and the first half of the 19th century in Central Europe new language-based national identities came to dominate over the o...
-
The Department of Political Science and Communication Studies of the University of Oradea, Romania organizes, between 24-25 May 2012, the In...
-
Funded studentship to research Pop Art in Eastern Europe The Critical Writing in Art and Design programme at the Royal College of Art (RCA) ...
No comments:
Post a Comment